I Bought a new CD and a Review is in Order
When I heard about this CD about three months ago, I knew I had to pick it up - if not for the music but for the fact that a portion of the proceeds from sales go to relief work in African villages ravaged by AIDS, I knew that even if I hated it, some of my money would go to something good.
So it's a cover album, and it's usually a crap shoot when you spend your hard earned cash on an album of "reinterpreted" songs that are already classics in your mind, and canonized to an extent. So it's a hard sell, unless the covers do two things:
1. Maintain the musical vision of the original
2. Add a special new twist that makes it as much the cover artists song as the original artist
And that's a hard thing to do, but it's something that In the Name of Love: Artists United For Africa seems to do well. It's not blow your mind great, but it's done well.
A Song By Song Breakdown
1. Sunday Bloody Sunday - Covered by Pillar - It was a great idea to open the album up with one of the greatest political songs ever written. Pillar wasn't an obvious choice that I would have seen on an album covering U2, but the band does a great job of maintaining the integrity of the original song (that guitar hook fashioned by the Edge remains virtually untouched, and that's a good thing..) but it's been made into a heavier and hard hitting ballad. I knew this cover was successful when I got instant chills when the first line I can't believe the news today... pounded through my car speakers.
2. Beautiful Day - Covered by Sanctus Real - I've never heard Sanctus Real, and I think I'm missing out. Given my disdain for most modern CCM (that being music released in the past ten years or so), I haven't seen a lot of new bands that I've picked up on. The problem with covering this song is that it's still fairly new - within the past four years. So the original still gets pretty regular airplay on radio - which can be a bad thing for what's a really good cover. The vocals are quite good, and the lead vocalist seems to have a pretty good range. Not as good as Bono, but not to bad.
3. 40 - Covered by Starfield - This is another band I've never heard of, and since this is one of my favorite U2 songs, I was skeptical. My skepticism was correct, in that, although this band sounds pretty good, the cover doesn't seem to have anything special - I'd rather listen to the original.
4. Love is Blindness - Coverd by Sixpence None the Richer - This is one of the few that I was really looking forward to on this CD. Sixpence is one of the greatest CCM bands to hit the mainstream in recent years because of their depth, their talent and the lyrical genius of Matt Slocum. No stranger to cover tunes, this song is one of their best, and perfect for their style. Leigh Nash does a wonderful job on vocals, and the musical arrangement is top notch - a great homage to a little-known-to-the-casual-fan U2 song.
5. Gloria - Covered by Audio Adrenaline - The lead singer of Audio Adrenaline seems to have slipped into a Steven Tyler (Aerosmith) vocal style, which suits him, but not this song. Another early U2 hit, this is a hard one to cover, since it's loved by many. Nothing really original is added, so it's sort of dull. Not terrible, just - dull.
6. Grace - Covered by Nichole Nordeman - Another later song, from All That You Can't Leave Behind. Nordeman is another artist I've only heard once or twice, and her version of one of the most ethereal and beatiful U2 songs of all time is very well done. Her vocal style is perfect, and the cover itself is very well orchestrated.
7. All I Want Is You - Covered by Jars of Clay - This is one of the other songs I was looking forward to on this CD. Jars, a breakout crossover band in the mid-nineties, has really grown over the past few years, and this song shows that growth. No longer a one trick pony (their first album, although good, sounded like one long continuous song), Jars takes a classic, and adds a wonderful bluesy/country vibe to it. Not what I expected, but very well done. I could have done without the faster pace, though.
8. Mysterious Ways - Covered by Toby Mac - Alright, I'll admit it. The idea of Toby Mac covering a U2 song frightened me almost to the point of sickness. I'm not a huge Toby Mac fan for various reasons, so I pondered the possibility, even prior to listening to the CD, of how I could possibly wipe that particular track off of the CD so as not to spoil my long term enjoyment. With low expectations going in, I was moderately surprised. No real rap involved in this cover, which is always a bright point with me, but it still was a mediocre cover at best.
9. Pride (In the Name of Love - Covered by Delirious? - Having Delirious? on this CD was a given. I've no doubt in my mind, had Delirious? been around in the early U2 days, we would have two great Christian bands in the mainstream, but alas, Delirious? showed up on the scene in the mid-nineties and have fast become one of the best CCM acts in recent memory. Their cover of the title track is great - a nice blend of classic U2 sound mixed with the trademark Delirious? effects. Definitely worthy of this CD and more.
10. One - Covered by Tait - Unlike my fear of Tait's bandmate Toby Macs cover, I was excited about this one. Michael Tait is a great vocalist, and probably one of the most worthy to cover a Bono sung U2 tune because of his immense range. I was not disappointed. This is one of my favorite U2 songs of all time, and Tait honors that with a passionate cover of it.
11. With Or Without You - Covered by GRITS (with Jadyn Maria) - This was the song I was least looking forward to, with reasons similar to the Toby Mac cover. I don't mind rap music, but it's not my cup of tea. When you mix it with textbook (i.e. unoriginal) R&B vocals from Jadyn Maria, you have an extremely sub-par homage to a band that deserves better. When it's an homage to possibly the greatest U2 song of the eighties, it's an error bordering on sacrilige.
12. When Love Comes to Town - Covered by Todd Agnew - Why have I not heard of almost half of the artists on this CD? Anyway, a good cover, with a nice twist. Nothing compared to the original, but a good cover nonetheless. Agnew's vocals are great.
13. Where the Streets Have No Name - Covered by Chris Tomlin - A worship leader on a rock CD? Nice touch. The original holds deep personal meaning for me, so a cover of it had to blow me away. And this one did. A brilliant homage to a great song about hope, which is what the people that the proceeds of this CD are going to need. A great way to close out the CD.
Overall Grade: B+
Points were shaved off for the inclusion of GRITS and the sub par contributions by Audio Adrenaline, Starfield and Toby Mac. U2 - a band that literally helped changed the face of music deserves better. But go out and buy it anyway - fifty cents of each purchase goes to AIDS Relief in Africa, or Go Here, make a donation and get free copy. It's worth it. |